Establishing the cause of erectile dysfunction is best
approached by considering the
normal controls of erection.29,30
Vascular insufficiency Inadequate erection caused by major
vascular
insufficiency occurs with aortoiliac atherosclerosis;
it is usually accompanied by
claudication and by diminished or absent femoral pulses.
The possibility that erectile dysfunction is caused by
disease of smaller arteries can
be pursued with modern hemodynamic techniques. Doppler
and ultrasound study can
delineate arterial, sinusoidal, or venous inadequacy.
Because these methods are not
widely available, the differential diagnosis is still
guided by clinical findings. If
injection of papaverine into the corpora cavernosa induces
a normal erection within
10 minutes, there is no need for further evaluation of
the vascular component.
Peripheral neuropathy Peripheral neurogenic erectile dysfunction
occurs as a
result of spinal cord trauma. It also occurs in the various
syndromes of autonomic
insufficiency and in about 50 percent of men with insulin-dependent
diabetes
mellitus.31 The medical history of men who have diabetes
usually discloses other
signs of neuropathy, such as postural hypotension, diarrhea,
and incontinence. The
erectile defect associated with diabetes may be impaired
relaxation of smooth muscle
of the corpora cavernosa. In vitro, smooth muscle relaxation
is impaired by either
direct electrical or neurochemical stimulation.32 The
absence of nocturnal penile
tumescence has been used to identify cases of neurologic
erectile dysfunction.
Drugs Many drug-related causes of erectile dysfunction
involve the complex
interconnections of the erotogenic pathways. Antihypertensive
drugs, tranquilizers,
antidepressants, and many other agents may all cause decreased
erectile capacity
[see Table 1]. 33 Hypertension and antihypertensive medications
are frequent
causes of erectile dysfunction.34 In one group of hypertensive
patients, 17 percent
reported some decrease in potency before they had begun
any treatment. Diuretics,
centrally active sympatholytics (including clonidine,
methyldopa, and reserpine), and
peripherally active agents may all induce partial or complete
erectile dysfunction;
some agents (e.g., guanethidine) can cause retrograde
ejaculation. Beta blockers may
produce erectile dysfunction with or without fatigue and
depression. The
mechanisms by which these drugs produce erectile dysfunction
are not well
understood, and it is impossible to predict which agent
will affect which patient. Trial
and error are therefore necessary to distinguish between
the pharmacological causes
of erectile dysfunction and the psychological influences
of the disease and its
treatment. Fortunately, angiotensin-converting enzyme
inhibitors and calcium
channel blockers do not seem to interfere with erectile
function.
Occasionally, drugs cause erectile dysfunction by affecting
the hormonal control of
erection. For example, spironolactone and cimetidine act
as antiandrogens.
Alcohol consumption Alcohol can cause erectile dysfunction
by many
mechanisms, but it is extremely difficult to untangle
its pharmacological effects from
its emotional and social impact. Alcohol is a direct central
nervous system depressant.
It can impair testosterone biosynthesis directly or through
liver disease (see below).
Alcohol dependence can be associated with spousal abuse
or general violence,
which may contribute to its negative psychological impact
on sexual function.
Epilepsy Erectile dysfunction may accompany temporal lobe
epilepsy. Some
patients with this disorder have hyperprolactinemia, but
in other patients, the erectile
difficulty has no obvious cause and may reflect abnormalities
in still unknown
pathways related to erectile function.
Systemic disorders Several systemic disorders, including
alcoholism, cirrhosis,
and uremia, can produce hypogonadism associated with a
low testosterone level.
Although the mechanisms involved remain to be elucidated,
the underlying disorder
should be corrected whenever possible. Some evidence suggests
that uremia
adversely affects steroidogenesis, producing a consequent
rise in gonadotropin level.
Therapy with clomiphene has been beneficial, but confirmation
of its effects is still
needed. Hyperprolactinemia and a low testosterone level
occur in chronic renal
failure, and bromocriptine therapy [see Subsection V]
can be helpful in lowering
the prolactin level.
Psychogenic factors Psychogenic factors are thought to
be the most frequent
cause of erectile dysfunction. Anxiety, fatigue, interpersonal
stresses, and chronic
illness are common underlying factors. Depression requires
separate mention
because of its frequency; erectile dysfunction may be
the presenting complaint that
leads to correct diagnosis and treatment. Endocrine abnormalities
The principal
endocrine abnormalities that lead to erectile dysfunction
include testosterone
deficiency from pituitary or testicular disease, estrogen
excess (e.g., caused by liver
disease), and hyperprolactinemic syndromes. Prolactin
excess exerts an
antigonadotropic effect manifested mainly by erectile
dysfunction, which is usually
associated with a low plasma testosterone level. However,
even after the plasma
testosterone level has been normalized, erectile dysfunction
can persist until the
hyperprolactinemia is corrected. Hyperthyroidism, Cushing's
syndrome, and
myxedema can each cause reversible erectile dysfunction.
When should evaluation for an endocrine cause of erectile
dysfunction be
undertaken? Patients with psychogenic erectile dysfunction
are often capable of
erection in some circumstances-for example, when masturbating
or when having sex
with a different partner. Endocrine erectile dysfunction,
on the other hand, tends to
develop gradually and then to be constant. Plasma testosterone
and prolactin levels
should be measured in any patient who has been impotent
in most circumstances for
more than three months. Abnormal levels of these hormones
may be indicative of
treatable organic disease. If a low testosterone level
is found, pituitary evaluation,
including measurement of serum FSH, LH, and prolactin
levels, is warranted.
One study that employed the plasma testosterone assay to
screen patients with
erectile dysfunction suggests that psychogenic erectile
dysfunction may not occur as
frequently as has been alleged.35 Of 105 patients tested,
37 were found to have
organic hypogonadism. Of these, 20 patients had hypothalamic-pituitary
deficiency,
seven had testicular failure, eight suffered from hyperprolactinemia,
and two had
occult hyperthyroidism. Although these relative frequencies
may not be
representative, the screening approach using the plasma
testosterone assay was
nonetheless invaluable.
EVALUATION AND TREATMENT OF ERECTILE dysfunction
As specific, treatable causes of erectile dysfunction are
further defined, it becomes
imperative to follow a protocol capable of detecting the
principal cause of
dysfunction in each patient. The starting point is a careful
history and physical
examination, combined with a detailed sexual history.
The patient should be asked
about duration of the symptom, the circumstances in which
it is manifested, the
potential role of disease or medication, and the possibility
of alcoholism or
depression. Physical examination should include testing
peripheral reflexes and
pinprick sensation in the perianal area. If any of the
specific conditions already
mentioned is suggested, the appropriate therapy is clear.
It is extremely important to
review all medications being taken and to prescribe a
substitute for any that may be
contributing to erectile dysfunction. In many patients,
no clear etiology is determined;
two additonal tests are then indicated.
The gold standard for noninvasive testing is the recording
of nocturnal penile
tumescence.36 This test can be done in a sleep laboratory,
but several devices are
available for use at home. With the RigiScan, measurements
of pressure at the base
and tip of the penis are recorded during natural sleep;
the record is read by a
computer, and a profile of pressures is printed out for
quantitative interpretation.37 In
this and other direct measurements, one can distinguish
between the presence of
some erection and the sustained achievement of sufficient
pressure for vaginal
penetration. Alternatively, a urologist can inject papaverine,
papaverine plus
phentolamine, or prostaglandin E1directly into the penile
corpora. A firm erection
achieved in this way indicates that the vascular component
of erection is adequate
and also provides an effective therapeutic alternative.
The failure to induce erection
should be followed by definitive vascular studies.
There is appropriate therapy for erectile dysfunction of
a specific cause (see below).
When no specific diagnosis is made, several options exist.
Long-term follow-up
studies indicate a generally high degree of patient and
partner satisfaction with intrac
avernous injection of vasoactive drugs.38,39 Injection
of papaverine alone or
papaverine with phentolamine induces an erection lasting
30 to 120 minutes in about
70 percent of patients. Side effects include pain, ecchymosis,
and occasional
episodes of priapism that require pharmacological intervention.40,41
Similar results
have been obtained with injections of prostaglandin E1.42
Intracavernous injection of
the synthetic prostaglandin E1 alpros tadil is approved
by the FDA for treatment of
erectile dysfunction.43,44 Intraurethral instillation
of alprostadil by a drug-delivery
system, MUSE (medicated urethral system for erection),
is reportedly effective in
inducing satisfactory erection in two thirds of men with
erectile dysfunction of
diverse causes.45 It is probably a bit less effective
than the direct injection.
An alternative to this invasive approach is the use of
a plastic tube and suction pump
to create a vacuum around the penis.46,47 When an erection
results, a rubber band is
placed at the base of the penis and satisfactory coitus
can occur. A third choice is
surgical implantation of one of several types of prostheses.
These have been used
successfully by many couples.48 Sex therapy is especially
helpful for psychogenic
erectile dysfunction. Supportive counseling and reassurance
are a necessary adjunct
for all patients with erectile dysfunction, particularly
because anxiety and fear of
failure compound any partial erectile difficulty. Two
drugs for oral treatment of
erectile dysfunction are under consideration by the FDA.
A new drug application has
been submitted for sildenafil, and an oral form of phentolamine
is in phase III trials.
Aging and Erectile Dysfunction
The most frequent clinical presentation of erectile dysfunction
is in apparently normal
men older than 50 years. The clinical significance of
any gradual decline in testicular
function in men older than 50 years is receiving renewed
study. Although there is
much individual variation, aging men generally experience
a gradual decline in
sexual activity. In some studies, the decrease in erectile
function has been associated
with decreased plasma levels of free testosterone.49 Other
studies have found that
although sexual dysfunction and hypogonadism each increase
with age, they are not
associated.17 Detailed correlative and, especially, longitudinal
studies of
psychosexual behavior are not yet available; thus, the
question whether such changes
are inevitable accompaniments of aging or whether they
reflect a partial decline in
testosterone secretion has not been answered definitively.
Diminished erectile capacity in older men should be evaluated
in the total context of
other illnesses, interpersonal relationships, physical
examination, and drugs being
taken. If there is no absolute barrier to sexual function
and if the plasma testoste rone
level is low normal or borderline (i.e., between 150 and
200 ng/dl), testosterone
therapy can be considered. If FSH and LH levels are low,
particularly if the plasma
testosterone level is strikingly depressed (i.e., <
100 ng/dl), serum prolactin and
thyroxine levels should be measured to exclude pituitary
insufficiency [see
Subsection V]. A rectal examination should be done, and
both prostate-specific
antigen and prostatic acid phosphatase levels should be
measured to exclude early
prostate carcinoma. If the resulting data are reassuring,
testosterone enanthate, 200
mg intramuscularly monthly, can be tried for three months.
If genuine improvement
in potency is obtained, long-term therapy can be considered
after the patient is
informed of the risks and benefits. In patients committed
to long-term treatment,
periodic rectal examination and prostate-specific antigen
determination are indicated
because testosterone therapy may stimulate a focus of
prostate carcinoma.50 In view
of this concern, other treatments for erectile dysfunction
should be given serious
consideration in the choice of therapy.